Decades before Brad Pitt got us all talking about his Fight Club physique, Marlon Brando rolled up the sleeves of a tight white T-shirt in A Streetcar Named Desire and had a whole generation of men trying to figure out how to grow a bigger set of arms.
You know the look. Broad chest, wide shoulders, and a set of pipes that look impressive, but attainable.
You’d be more than forgiven for thinking there was a comprehensive workout regimen behind it all, and a structured diet plan alongside it.
But what we know about Brando’s approach to training and nutrition flies in the face of what seems to be the biggest fitness buzzword right now: consistency. Because if there’s one thing The Godfather wasn’t, it’s consistent.
Boxing, Running, Weightlifting and… Smoking?
Here was a man who could impress a professional boxer with how quickly he picked up a left hook, lose 10kg on a promise to a director, then put it all back on again before they’d finished making the film.
And if you’ve ever scoffed down a dessert while explaining to the person opposite you that you’re trying to lose a bit of weight, well, you and one of Hollywood’s great leading men have something in common.
What to read next
In 1947, screenwriter Truman Capote described Brando as having ‘the weight-lifter’s arms, the Charles Atlas chest’. In fact, he stood out so much among the slighter physiques of the day that Capote mistook him for a burly stagehand.
How much actual weightlifting went into arming those guns is difficult to pin down. We know that Brando studied movement with dancers and choreographers, but that he found a rather less graceful outlet for his energy.
Between stage appearances, he and some of the backstage crew would head down to the theatre’s boiler room to box. One session ended with Brando walking himself to hospital.
For his first film, The Men, in which he played a veteran with a spinal cord injury, the producer offered to put him up in a Hollywood hotel. Brando instead spent the four weeks before production living on a 32-bed hospital ward, learning from the men there how to handle a wheelchair and transfer himself from bed to chair using his arms.
There are dozens of pictures of Brando lifting weights behind the scenes of The Men, obviously keen to embody the strong upper-body physicality and grit of the WWII veteran he was portraying.
Based on the images, Brando relied on a blend of classic lifts and bodyweight basics, such as barbell presses, chest flyes, triceps extensions, deadlifts, push-ups, pull-ups and dips.
Slightly less advisable are the cigarettes Brando is seen chain-smoking mid-workout.
By 1954’s On the Waterfront, Brando’s boxing education had progressed beyond the boiler room. To play a former prizefighter now working the docks, he trained with retired professional middleweight Roger Donoghue.
The pair did roadwork – long, slow runs, in boxing parlance – through Central Park and put in rounds at New York’s Stillman’s Gym. Given how firmly bodyweight work features in boxing conditioning, we’d wager a few push-ups and sit-ups found their way into those sessions, too, and that Brando kept up his weightlifting habit.
Donoghue’s job was to teach Brando to move convincingly enough that we’d buy him as a man who could handle himself in a ring. He definitely exceeded the brief.
‘I can make a helluva fighter out of this kid!’ the boxer is recorded as remarking.
A History of Yo-Yo Dieting
A less successful piece of direction came a few years later, when Sayonara director Joshua Logan asked Brando to lose 5-10kg.
Brando had managed to lose most of that before arriving in Japan, where he promptly regained the lot, with interest.
‘I’m supposed to be on a diet,’ he told a friend at dinner before wolfing down steak and chips, spaghetti, bread and butter, and cheese and crackers. When the waitress checked whether he’d also like some apple pie, Brando reportedly sighed.
‘With ice cream, honey.’
More evidence for Brando’s unsustainable yo-yo approach comes from the roles that followed. For 1966’s The Appaloosa, he promised the director he’d lose 10kg. According to biographer Peter Manso, he did just that, then regained it during the shoot.
Six years later, the problem ran in the opposite direction. Another biographer recalls that by the time Brando came to play Don Corleone in The Godfather, ‘he had to wear padding’ because he’d lost too much weight for the part.
There were more troubling extremes. Ahead of Apocalypse Now, Brando admitted himself to a Los Angeles hospital for supervised fasting in an attempt to slim down for the role of Colonel Kurtz.
And late in life, after doctors advised him to lose weight, his friend George Englund recalled Brando devising a diet largely consisting of greens, lemon juice and plain fish. Englund estimated he lost around 30kg.
In Englund’s memoir Marlon Brando in Private, he said of the aftermath of this diet: ‘He was weak, his muscle tone was nearly gone.’
If you’re looking for something sensible to take away from Brando’s diet, this certainly isn’t it.
Why Do Hollywood Stars Keep Following Extreme Fitness Regimes?
You’d think, in the decades since Brando, Hollywood’s leading men might have found a way of getting in shape that they could actually live with.
After Spectre, Daniel Craig remarked that he’d ‘rather break this glass and slash my wrists’ than get back to his Bond physique again. Zac Efron was talking specifically about his Baywatch physique when he said, ‘I don’t ever want to be in that good of shape again.’
And given that getting there involved gruelling workouts, a restrictive diet and diuretics, who can blame him?
But that does rather explain why this keeps happening. Go about getting in shape in a way you can barely tolerate and, sooner or later, you’ll be glad to give it up. Then the next role comes along and you’re back where you started.
A more sustainable, enjoyable plan that you can actually stick to all year round, before slightly turning up the dial when necessary, is not just more conducive to health, but happiness.
Find a plan you like, or at the very least don’t hate. Eat in a way that supports both performance and preference, without leaving you feeling miserable, deflated and always one thought away from an unmitigated blowout.
And feel free to explore different options when what’s working now stops working.
And if in doubt, just roll your sleeves up.
With almost 18 years in the health and fitness space as a personal trainer, nutritionist, breath coach and writer, Andrew has spent nearly half of his life exploring how to help people improve their bodies and minds.
As our fitness editor he prides himself on keeping Men’s Health at the forefront of reliable, relatable and credible fitness information, whether that’s through writing and testing thousands of workouts each year, taking deep dives into the science behind muscle building and fat loss or exploring the psychology of performance and recovery.
Whilst constantly updating his knowledge base with seminars and courses, Andrew is a lover of the practical as much as the theory and regularly puts his training to the test tackling everything from Crossfit and strongman competitions, to ultra marathons, to multiple 24 hour workout stints and (extremely unofficial) world record attempts.
You can find Andrew on Instagram at @theandrew.tracey, or simply hold up a sign for ‘free pizza’ and wait for him to appear.
