THERE’S SOMETHING special about the first chill in the air after Labor Day. We all pack up our swimsuits and sandals to break out the hoodies, shackets, and cashmere sweaters. Somehow, our homes start to smell like the pumpkin patch photos that flood our Instagram feed, while we can’t seem to escape the marketing of the #PSL craze (are they even that good!?).

While we’re unsure if #PSLs live up to their hype, there’s one thing other than Football Sundays we get excited about. Enter: beanie season. Whether you’re off to a tailgate before a big game, commuting to work, or dressing up for an evening on the town, a beanie is your favorite companion to keep you warm and stylish on those chilly fall nights and into the depths of winter.

Beanies come in a range of styles, fits and materials—some more optimal than others when it comes to fashion and performance. When you’re shopping for a beanie this season, you’ll first want to consider the activity it’s being used for. Are you looking for a lightweight winter hat you can sweat in? Are you needing an everyday commuter? Or something of designer sorts to impress?

We tapped our style and gear expert to bring you the best 23 beanies of the season, considering fashion, function, editor-testing, and customer reviews. From innovative materials like merino wool for athletics, to a cozy cashmere for the ultra-luxe feel, and the classic fisherman knit for the urban outdoorsman, you’ll find all the best beanies for winter at all different price points. Get ready to shop for a few new hats this season for a better, more stylish winter. You’re going to need all the help you can get.

Read more: Warmest Socks for Winter